Knee injuries such as anterior cruciate ligament injuries (ACL injuries), posterior cruciate ligament injuries (PCL
injuries), medial collateral ligament injuries (MCL
injuries), and lateral collateral ligament injuries (LCL
injuries) are common occurrences in day-to-day life and especially so for those participating in high-demand
sports such as amongst others, running, soccer, and cricket.
However, whether you require a surgical intervention will be decided by the severity of the injury.
The article discusses the anatomy of the ACL tear (Anterior Cruciate Ligament tear), the common
causes of tears, indicative symptoms, and treatment options.
What Causes an ACL Tear?
The ACL tears when excessive force is applied to the knee, usually in sports injury, fall or motor
vehicle accidents. It occurs when the knee is twisted or jerked forward beyond a certain limit. ACL tear is common
in certain sports such as football and
The tear can be partial or all the way through the ACL.
What is an Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) in the Knee?
There are four ligaments that stabilise the knee joint. Two of them are located outside the knee joint and the other
two are located inside the joint (intraarticular). These intraarticular ligaments cross each other in a cross-like
formation and are therefore known as cruciate ligaments. The front intraarticular ligament is known as the Anterior
Cruciate Ligament (ACL).
This ligament connects the bottom of the thigh bone (femur) to the top of the shin bone (tibia).
What are ACL Injury Symptoms and Signs?
People who tear their ACL often hear a popping sound in their knee at the time of the injury.
- Immediately after injury of the ACL, there will be significant pain and swelling at the knee
- Swelling normally occurs over a few hours
- Difficulty walking initially after injury
- The pain and swelling subsides after some time, but the knee remains unstable
- After the initial recovery, the patient usually experiences episodes of knee giving way specially when twisting
A torn ACL can be diagnosed by an orthopaedic specialist through:
- A physical examination
Can a Completely Torn ACL Heal Without Surgery?
Partial ACL tears can usually be treated with the help of physiotherapy and specific exercises.
However, a completely torn ACL cannot heal by itself. The knee joint is filled with synovial fluid,
which prevents blood clot formation and torn ligaments to come into contact. Therefore, ACL cannot heal without
surgery unlike the ligaments outside
the joints, which have good healing potential.
If a torn ACL is left untreated, the patient may be predisposed to other knee injuries such as
meniscus tear and may develop osteoarthritis.
That said, the need for surgery is dependent on:
- The extent of the injury
- The type of activities/sports that a person is involved in his day-to-day routine
- Other injuries in the knee area
- If the knee feels too unstable during walking
Most ACL repair surgeries are done arthroscopically using a small camera and instruments that are
inserted through incisions.
How Long Is the Torn ACL Injury Recovery Time After Surgery?
The recovery time after an ACL surgery is usually 6 to 12 months. Physiotherapy might be constantly
needed during and after the recovery period.
What is the Treatment for an ACL Tear in a Knee?
Although ACL cannot heal by itself, many patients will cope well without
surgery, especially those with a sedentary lifestyle with low physical demands.
The injury should immediately be followed by rest, ice, compression, and
elevation techniques. Analgesics should immediately be given after an ACL injury to reduce pain. Additionally,
providing physiotherapy treatment will improve the function of
the knee over time.
Without surgical treatment, those with torn ACL should not participate in
high demand activities that require jumping and pivoting.
Surgery is recommended for young and physically active patients.
ACL reconstruction is done by replacing the torn ligament with a tendon
either from the patient (autograft) or from a donor (allograft).
This surgery is normally conducted with arthroscopy (keyhole surgery).
What is an Arthroscopy?
Arthroscopy is the procedure of inserting a telescope into the knee and is connected to a monitor, so
that the inside of the knee can be visualised. Through another small hole (portal), instruments are inserted into
the knee to reconstruct the ligament.
What Should I Do After Surgery?
After surgery, the patient will have to protect the operated ligament by using crutches or knee brace
for about a month. The patient can usually walk unaided after one month and can start jogging after four months.
Depending on muscle strength, the
patient may be able to resume sports activities after about nine months.
Physical therapy (PT) may be needed during the recovery period to regain the original range of motion
and flexibility, improve knee strength, reduce pain and swelling, and to improve balance and coordination.
What is the Prognosis of an Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury (ACL Injury)?
Although there have been occasional cases of partially torn ACL healing on its own, ACL almost never
heal by itself. With accurate placement of graft and adequate rehabilitation, a patient undergoing ACL surgery can
anticipate 85% to 90% recovery.
Is it Possible to Prevent an ACL Tear?
Several studies have shown that muscle-strengthening and proprioception training can reduce the
incidence of ACL tear in high physical demand athletes.
It has also been noted that if you have once had an ACL tear, the chances of having it again are
Adhering to strict rules of sports and with regular training (like neuromuscular training, and
balance training), ACL injury can be reduced in professional sports.